Which Broker is Best for Option Trading in Australia?

Table of Contents

1. Executive Summary

This report provides a comprehensive evaluation of brokerage firms suitable for trading Australian Securities Exchange (ASX) listed options, commonly known as Exchange Traded Options (ETOs), within Australia. The objective is to assist investors in selecting a broker that aligns with their specific trading needs, cost sensitivity, platform preferences, and support requirements. The analysis focuses on brokers licensed by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) and confirmed to offer access to ASX ETOs.

Key evaluation criteria include the range of ASX options products (equity and index options), the complete structure of associated costs (commissions, exercise/assignment fees, platform and data fees), the capabilities of the trading platforms (analytical tools, strategy builders, execution quality), the availability of relevant educational resources and customer support, regulatory standing, and market reputation derived from user feedback and independent reviews.

Leading contenders in the Australian market for ASX ETOs include Interactive Brokers (IBKR), Commonwealth Securities (CommSec), Nabtrade, CMC Markets, and Bell Direct. Interactive Brokers stands out for its exceptionally low commission rates and highly sophisticated trading platform, making it attractive for cost-sensitive and advanced traders, though its platform presents a steeper learning curve. CommSec and Nabtrade, backed by major Australian banks, offer integrated banking convenience and simpler platforms, potentially appealing to those valuing ease of use, albeit generally at a higher cost. CMC Markets and Bell Direct (often utilizing the IRESS platform) present alternative choices with varying fee structures and platform features.

Ultimately, the “best” broker depends on individual priorities. Cost-focused, active traders may gravitate towards IBKR, while those prioritizing platform simplicity and integration with existing banking relationships might prefer CommSec or Nabtrade. This report provides the detailed comparative data necessary to make an informed decision.

related posts : Best Binary OptionS Brokers (in 2025)

2. Introduction: Navigating the ASX Options Market

The Australian Securities Exchange (ASX) provides a regulated marketplace for trading Exchange Traded Options (ETOs). These are standardized contracts giving the buyer the right, but not the obligation, to buy (call option) or sell (put option) an underlying asset at a specified price (strike price) on or before a certain date (expiry date). The primary types of ASX ETOs are Equity Options, based on the shares of individual ASX-listed companies, and Index Options, based on market indices like the S&P/ASX 200 (XJO).¹

Investors utilize ASX ETOs for various strategic purposes, including hedging existing share portfolios against adverse price movements, generating income through strategies like writing covered calls, or speculating on the future direction of share prices or market indices with leverage.² Unlike Over-The-Counter (OTC) derivatives, ASX ETOs are exchange-traded and centrally cleared by ASX Clear, providing standardization and mitigating counterparty risk.³

The choice of a brokerage firm is critical for accessing this market. The broker acts as the intermediary, providing the trading platform, executing orders, managing the account, and ensuring regulatory compliance.⁴ Selecting the right broker involves careful consideration of factors beyond mere market access. Costs, platform functionality tailored to options trading complexities, available analytical tools, order execution reliability, and customer support quality can significantly impact a trader’s efficiency, profitability, and overall experience. Furthermore, ensuring the broker is regulated by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) is paramount for investor protection.⁵ This report aims to dissect these critical factors across various Australian brokers offering ASX ETOs.

3. Methodology

The evaluation process employed in this report involved several structured steps to ensure a comprehensive and objective comparison of brokers for ASX options trading:

Broker Identification: Potential brokers were identified primarily through the official ASX list of market participants authorized to trade ETOs.⁸ This list was supplemented by cross-referencing information from reputable financial comparison websites and industry reports focusing on Australian brokers.⁹
Service Verification: Each identified broker’s services were verified to confirm the specific offering of ASX ETOs, distinct from international options (e.g., US options) or Contracts for Difference (CFDs) on options. This involved reviewing broker websites, product disclosure statements (PDS), and financial services guides (FSG) where available.³
Cost Structure Analysis: Detailed fee schedules were obtained directly from broker websites or reliable third-party comparison data.¹¹ Costs analyzed included per-contract commissions, minimum charges, exercise and assignment fees, platform access fees, market data subscriptions, inactivity fees, and currency conversion costs (though less critical for pure ASX ETO trading in AUD). ASX Clear’s own fees were noted as a baseline component.¹
Platform Feature Evaluation: Trading platforms were assessed based on features crucial for options trading, as described in broker documentation, platform guides, and independent reviews. Key features included options chain displays, integrated calculation and display of Greeks, implied volatility tools, strategy builders, multi-leg order capabilities, and the functionality across desktop, web, and mobile interfaces.⁹
Educational and Support Assessment: The availability and relevance of educational materials specifically addressing options trading were reviewed.⁴ Customer support channels, responsiveness, and perceived expertise in handling options-related queries were evaluated based on broker disclosures and user feedback.⁹
Regulatory Compliance Check: Each broker’s status as an Australian Financial Services License (AFSL) holder regulated by ASIC was confirmed using broker disclosures and cross-referencing with ASIC’s professional registers where necessary.³ Client fund protection mechanisms mentioned by brokers were noted.³
Reputation Analysis: User reviews from financial forums (e.g., Reddit’s AusFinance) and ratings from independent comparison sites were synthesized to gauge market perception regarding platform stability, customer service quality, and overall user satisfaction with options trading services.⁶

The scope of this report is strictly focused on brokers facilitating the trading of ASX-listed ETOs for retail investors in Australia. Brokers solely offering international options, CFDs, or other derivatives without direct ASX ETO access were excluded from the detailed comparison, although they may be mentioned for context.

4. Identifying Licensed Brokers Offering ASX Options (ETOs)

A fundamental requirement for any broker operating in Australia is authorization from the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), signified by holding an Australian Financial Services License (AFSL).⁵ This regulation provides a framework for consumer protection, including requirements for fair dealing, disclosure, and dispute resolution.

However, simply holding an AFSL does not guarantee a broker offers ASX ETOs. Many ASIC-regulated brokers focus on other products like international shares, Contracts for Difference (CFDs), or foreign exchange (Forex).⁵ Furthermore, the term “options trading” is frequently used in marketing materials to refer to options on US markets, which are significantly larger and often promoted more heavily.¹¹ Investors specifically seeking to trade options listed on the ASX must verify that a broker explicitly provides access to ASX ETOs.

The most reliable starting point for identifying brokers equipped for ASX ETO trading is the ASX’s own list of participating organisations.⁸ This list categorizes brokers and indicates the products they are authorized to trade, including ETOs. Based on this list and cross-verification with broker information, the following firms are confirmed as ASIC-regulated and offer ASX ETO trading capabilities:

Table 1: ASIC Licensed Brokers Offering ASX ETOs

Broker Name	ASIC License (AFSL)	Confirmed ASX ETO Offering	Broker Type (per ASX List)	Primary Source Confirmation
Interactive Brokers Australia Pty Ltd	453554	Yes	Online	ASX List, Broker Website ³
Commonwealth Securities Limited	238814	Yes	Online	ASX List, Broker Website ⁴
CMC Markets Stockbroking Limited	238054	Yes	Online	ASX List, Review Sites ⁸
Bell Direct	246906	Yes	Online	ASX List, Review Sites ⁸
nabtrade (National Australia Bank)	243430	Yes	Online	ASX List, Broker Website ⁷
Webull Securities (Australia) Pty Ltd	536980	Yes	Online	ASX List, Broker Website ⁸
Bell Potter Securities Limited	243480	Yes	Full Service	ASX List ⁸
Ord Minnett Limited	237121	Yes	Full Service	ASX List ⁸
Morgans Financial Limited	235410	Yes	Full Service	ASX List ⁸
Shaw and Partners Limited	236048	Yes	Full Service	ASX List ⁸
Macquarie Equities Limited	237504	Yes	Full Service	ASX List ⁸
Morgan Stanley Wealth Management	411937	Yes	Full Service	ASX List ⁸
Other Full Service/Wholesale	Various	Yes	Full Service / Wholesale	ASX List ⁸

Note: This table focuses on brokers accessible to retail investors. Several wholesale and full-service brokers also offer ETOs but may have higher minimums or focus on advised clients.

It is important to distinguish these brokers from others who might be well-known but do not offer ASX ETOs. For instance, eToro is ASIC regulated ⁵ but focuses on shares, ETFs, crypto, and copy trading, primarily US and ASX shares, not ASX options.⁹ Tiger Brokers is also ASIC regulated and offers low-cost access to ASX shares and US options, but not ASX ETOs.⁹ Tastytrade Australia holds an AFSL ¹⁷ but facilitates access to US options trading via its US-based affiliate.¹⁶ IG offers various options products, but these appear to be primarily CFDs or barrier options rather than direct ASX ETOs.²¹

The distinction between “Online” and “Full Service” brokers on the ASX list ⁸ also warrants attention. Online brokers typically provide execution-only services with lower fees, relying on the client to make their own trading decisions using the provided platform and tools. Full-service brokers often provide investment advice, research, and potentially higher levels of personal support, usually accompanied by significantly higher brokerage fees.²² For self-directed options traders primarily concerned with platform capability and cost efficiency, online brokers are generally the more relevant category.

5. Range of ASX Options Products Available

Brokers authorized to trade ASX ETOs generally provide access to the two main categories of options listed on the exchange:

ASX Equity Options: These are options contracts written on the shares of specific, typically larger and more liquid, ASX-listed companies. They allow traders to take positions on the future price movements of individual stocks. Most online brokers offering ASX ETOs, such as CommSec ⁴ and Interactive Brokers ³, facilitate trading in these single-stock options.
ASX Index Options: These contracts are based on underlying market indices, with the most prominent being options on the S&P/ASX 200 Index (XJO). Index options allow traders to gain exposure to, or hedge against, movements in the broader Australian market, rather than just individual companies. The availability of index options is crucial for portfolio-level hedging or implementing market-wide trading strategies. ASX Clear explicitly lists fees for index options, confirming their place in the market structure.¹ Brokers like Interactive Brokers, with their comprehensive global market access ³, are highly likely to offer ASX index options alongside equity options. Major bank brokers like CommSec and Nabtrade also typically cover both.

While most brokers offering ASX ETOs are expected to provide access to both equity and index options, the practical availability and liquidity of specific contracts can sometimes differ. The ASX determines which stocks have options listed and the available strike prices and expiry dates. However, a broker’s platform interface, data feeds, and order routing systems might influence the ease with which traders can access and trade less common or less liquid contracts. While the underlying market is the same, the broker’s technology layer can affect the user experience, particularly for options that are far out-of-the-money or have distant expiry dates.

Furthermore, the range of underlying stocks for which equity options are available might vary slightly, although most brokers will cover the actively traded options series. Traders interested in options on specific mid-cap or smaller companies should verify their availability with the chosen broker. The critical consideration for strategic flexibility is ensuring the broker offers both equity and index options, as limiting access to only one type would significantly restrict the range of potential trading and hedging strategies available.¹

6. Comparative Cost Analysis: Unpacking the Fees

The cost structure for trading ASX options is multi-faceted and can significantly impact profitability, especially for active traders. It extends beyond the headline commission rate and includes various other charges levied by the broker and the exchange/clearing house. A thorough comparison requires examining all potential fees.

Trading Commissions: This is often the most visible cost. Brokers may charge:

A flat fee per contract (e.g., $X per contract).
A percentage of the premium value or the underlying value of the trade.
A combination, often with a minimum charge per transaction or per leg of a multi-leg strategy. Interactive Brokers is known for its low commission rates, charging between AUD 0.50 and AUD 2.00 per Australian option contract, depending on the premium value, with a minimum of AUD 1.10 per order for ASX options mentioned elsewhere.¹¹ CommSec’s options pricing is cited as 0.24% or a minimum of $24.95 per leg ¹², though their standard share trading fees vary significantly based on trade size and settlement method.¹⁴ Other brokers like Bell Direct (0.35% or $34.95 min/leg), CMC Markets (0.30% or $30 min/leg), and Nabtrade (0.35% or $34.95 min/leg) also typically employ percentage-based fees with substantial minimums.¹² Some brokers may offer tiered pricing, reducing costs for very high-volume traders.¹¹

A critical point often overlooked is the impact of minimum commissions. A broker advertising a low per-contract fee might still be expensive for small trades if a high minimum charge applies per transaction or, particularly relevant for spreads, per leg.¹² For example, trading just two contracts with a $1 per contract fee but a $25 minimum charge results in an effective cost of $12.50 per contract, not $1. This makes comparing minimums essential for traders who typically deal in smaller contract numbers per order.

Exercise and Assignment Fees: When an option is exercised by the buyer or assigned to the seller, brokers may charge an additional fee on top of any commission for the resulting share transaction. ASX Clear also charges small fees ($0.05 per contract for exercise/assignment on single stock options, $0.30-$0.35 for index options) ¹, but broker fees can be considerably higher. These fees need to be factored into the profitability calculation for strategies that commonly involve exercise or assignment.

Platform and Data Fees: Access to trading platforms, especially premium versions like IRESS used by some brokers ¹², or specialized platforms like IBKR’s Trader Workstation ¹⁵, may incur monthly subscription fees. Furthermore, accessing real-time, streaming ASX ETO market data (essential for active trading) often comes at a cost, which can range from around $10 to over $80 per month depending on the broker and the level of data depth.¹² Some brokers might waive these fees if certain trading volume thresholds are met, benefiting active traders but adding a recurring cost for others. Webull notes free real-time data for US/AU markets but offers premium ASX streaming data as a subscription.¹⁹ CommSec also mentions potential data fees.¹⁴ These recurring costs can easily outweigh commission differences for frequent traders needing live data and advanced tools.

Inactivity Fees: Some brokers penalize accounts that do not meet minimum trading activity levels or balance requirements.¹⁰ Interactive Brokers explicitly states no inactivity fees.⁹ Others, particularly some bank-affiliated brokers, might charge such fees.⁷

Other Fees: Be aware of potential charges for account maintenance (though less common for basic online accounts), phone orders (often significantly more expensive than online trades ¹⁴), deposit/withdrawal fees (IBKR offers one free wire withdrawal per month ¹³), or fees for transferring positions.¹³

ASX Clear Fees: It’s important to remember that brokers pass on fees charged by ASX Clear for trade registration ($0.06 – $0.31 per contract for single stock options, $0.45 for index options) and exercise/assignment.¹ These are standard market costs, but brokers’ own fees are layered on top.

Table 2: Indicative Fee Comparison for ASX Options Trading (AUD)

Broker Name	ASX ETO Commission (per contract/%, min)	Minimum Commission per Trade/Leg	Exercise Fee (Broker)	Assignment Fee (Broker)	Platform Access Fee (Monthly)	Real-Time Data Fee (Monthly)	Inactivity Fee
Interactive Brokers	$0.50-$2.00/contract (ASX) or $0.33/contract, min $1.10 ¹¹	~$1.10-$6.00 (Varies by source)	Check Broker	Check Broker	$0	Check Broker (Potentially tiered)	$0 ¹¹
CommSec	0.24% or $24.95 min/leg ¹²	$24.95 ¹²	Check Broker	Check Broker	$0 (Std), Potential for Pro	~$10 – $82.50 ¹²	$0 (Std)
CMC Markets	0.30% or $30 min/leg ¹²	$30 ¹²	Check Broker	Check Broker	$0 (Std), IRESS possible	~$27.50 – $49+ ¹²	Check Broker
Bell Direct	0.35% or $34.95 min/leg ¹²	$34.95 ¹²	Check Broker	Check Broker	$0 (Std), IRESS possible	~$27.50 – $49+ ¹²	Check Broker
Nabtrade	0.35% or $34.95 min/leg ¹²	$34.95 ¹²	Check Broker	Check Broker	$0 (Std), Premium tiers exist	Check Broker	Potential ⁷
Webull	Check Broker (ASX ETO fees not specified in snippets)	Check Broker	Check Broker	Check Broker	$0	Free (Basic), Streaming Sub. ¹⁹	$0

Note: Fees are indicative based on available snippets and can change. Exercise/Assignment fees and specific data costs often require direct confirmation with the broker. Minimums per leg can significantly increase costs for multi-leg strategies.

The tendency for some low-cost brokers to recoup revenue via other means, such as high FX fees on international trading ²³ or payment for order flow (more common in the US), is less directly applicable to ASX ETOs traded in AUD. However, the overall business model can influence the quality and cost of ancillary services like data feeds or platform development for less mainstream products like ASX options. Bank-affiliated brokers ⁴ may offer convenience but often charge premium rates ¹², leveraging their brand trust and existing customer base.

7. Trading Platform Evaluation for Options Traders

The trading platform is the options trader’s primary toolkit. Its capabilities, or lack thereof, directly influence the ability to analyze opportunities, construct strategies, manage risk, and execute trades efficiently. Evaluation must focus on features specifically relevant to the complexities of options trading.

Analysis Tools: Essential tools include:

Options Chains: Clear display of available strike prices, expiry dates, premiums (bid/ask), volume, and open interest for an underlying asset.
Greeks: Real-time calculation and display of Delta, Gamma, Theta, Vega, and Rho. Understanding these risk parameters is fundamental to managing options positions.
Implied Volatility (IV): Access to current and historical implied volatility data, IV charting, and potentially volatility skew analysis. IV is a critical input for options pricing and strategy selection.
Payoff Diagrams: Visual tools that graph the potential profit or loss of an option position or strategy across a range of underlying prices at expiry.

Strategy Builders and Order Execution:

Multi-Leg Strategy Tools: Platforms should allow users to easily build and analyze complex strategies (e.g., vertical spreads, iron condors, butterflies) and ideally submit them as a single order to minimize execution risk (legging risk).
Order Types: Beyond standard market and limit orders, support for stop-loss, conditional orders, and potentially algorithmic orders can be beneficial for risk management and execution precision.
Execution Quality: While harder to quantify externally, factors like perceived order execution speed, reliability (especially during market volatility), and whether the broker offers Direct Market Access (DMA) can be important, particularly for active traders.

Platform Environment:

Platform Types: Brokers typically offer platforms via downloadable desktop software (often the most feature-rich, e.g., IBKR’s Trader Workstation (TWS) ¹⁵), web browser interfaces (more accessible, varying features), and mobile apps (convenience, but potentially limited functionality).⁹
User Interface (UI): A balance is needed between comprehensive features and usability. Platforms like TWS are powerful but known for complexity and a steep learning curve.⁹ Simpler platforms, often from bank brokers like CommSec ⁴, may be more intuitive for basic trading but lack advanced analytical capabilities.¹² Some brokers like Bell Direct and CMC Markets may offer access to third-party platforms like IRESS ViewPoint ¹², known for its professional features but often incurring data fees.
Charting: High-quality charting for the underlying asset, ideally with the ability to overlay technical indicators and analyze price action, is crucial context for options trading decisions.
Integration: Seamless integration between options trading, share trading, account management, and reporting within a single platform enhances workflow efficiency. IBKR’s universal account structure is designed for this.³

Broker Platform Specifics:

Interactive Brokers: Offers the highly sophisticated Trader Workstation (TWS), IBKR Desktop, web platform (Client Portal), and mobile apps.¹⁵ TWS is renowned for its extensive options analytics, strategy builders, global access, and low costs but is often considered complex for beginners.⁹
CommSec: Provides a proprietary web platform and mobile app, generally regarded as user-friendly.⁴ While offering ETO access, its options-specific analytical tools may be less comprehensive than dedicated platforms.¹²
Nabtrade: Offers its own platform, potentially with premium tiers providing enhanced charting and alerts.¹⁰ Likely aims for ease of use, similar to CommSec.
CMC Markets: Offers its “Next Generation” platform and potentially IRESS.¹² Known for CFDs but also provides ASX ETOs ⁸; the depth of options tools on its proprietary platform versus IRESS should be investigated. User feedback suggests external tools might be needed alongside it for valuation.¹⁶
Bell Direct: Primarily utilizes the IRESS platform ¹², offering advanced charting and market data capabilities, often preferred by active traders but typically involves data subscription fees.
Webull: Promotes its platform’s advanced tools, including options-specific features like Option Builder and Screeners ¹⁹, but the marketing focus is heavily on US options. The functionality and tools available specifically for ASX ETOs need careful verification.

A significant consideration is the trade-off between platform power and usability. Advanced traders requiring sophisticated analytics and multi-leg strategy support often gravitate towards platforms like TWS or IRESS, accepting the learning curve.⁹ Newer or less complex traders might prefer the simpler interfaces of bank brokers, potentially sacrificing some analytical depth.⁴

Furthermore, the necessity of integrated, real-time data and analytics (Greeks, IV) cannot be overstated for serious options trading. Relying on external tools or delayed data ¹⁶ introduces inefficiency and risk. The quality and feature parity across desktop, web, and mobile versions also vary; complex analysis and multi-leg orders are often best handled on desktop platforms, even if mobile apps offer basic trading.⁹

Table 3: Indicative Options Trading Platform Feature Comparison

Broker Name	Platform(s) Offered	Options Chain	Integrated Greeks	IV Data	Strategy Builder	Multi-Leg Orders	Payoff Diagram	Mobile Options Func.	UI Rating (Est.)
Interactive Brokers	Desktop (TWS/IBKR), Web, Mobile ¹⁵	Advanced	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Advanced	Complex
CommSec	Web, Mobile ⁴	Standard	Check Broker	Check Broker	Limited/No	Check Broker	Check Broker	Basic/Standard	Simple
CMC Markets	Web (Proprietary/IRESS), Mobile ¹²	Standard/Adv	Check Broker	Check Broker	Check Broker	Check Broker	Check Broker	Standard	Moderate
Bell Direct	Web (IRESS), Mobile ¹²	Advanced	Yes (IRESS)	Yes (IRESS)	Yes (IRESS)	Yes (IRESS)	Yes (IRESS)	Standard/Advanced	Moderate/Complex
Nabtrade	Web, Mobile ¹⁰	Standard	Check Broker	Check Broker	Limited/No	Check Broker	Check Broker	Basic/Standard	Simple/Moderate
Webull	Desktop, Web, Mobile ¹⁹	Advanced (US)	Yes (US)	Yes (US)	Yes (US) ²⁰	Yes (US)	Yes (US)	Advanced (US)	Moderate

Note: Features listed are indicative. “Check Broker” indicates information not readily available in snippets or requiring direct verification for ASX ETOs specifically. UI Rating is subjective based on general perception and descriptions. Webull features are confirmed for US options; ASX ETO feature parity needs verification.

8. Educational Resources and Customer Support

Given the inherent complexity and risks associated with options trading, adequate educational resources and knowledgeable customer support are valuable assets, particularly for less experienced traders.

Educational Resources: Many brokers offer educational materials, ranging from articles and videos to webinars and structured courses.⁴ CommSec has its ‘CommSec Learn’ section ⁴, CMC Markets provides a knowledge hub ¹⁰, eToro offers various resources including a trading school ⁹, and Interactive Brokers also provides educational content.³ Platforms like Tastytrade (focused on US options) are built heavily around educational content.¹⁷ Some brokers like CMC Markets and Webull offer demo or paper trading accounts, allowing users to practice strategies without risking real capital.¹⁰

However, a potential gap exists between generic investment education and content specifically tailored to the nuances of ASX ETOs. Much educational material may focus on basic share investing ⁴, CFDs ¹⁰, or the larger US options market.¹⁷ Finding in-depth resources covering ASX-specific contract specifications, strategies suitable for the Australian market context, and local regulatory/tax implications might require looking beyond the broker’s standard offerings.⁹ Users may need to supplement broker materials with independent courses or resources, as suggested by user comments indicating reliance on external tools even when using established broker platforms.¹⁶

Customer Support: Access to responsive and knowledgeable customer support is crucial when dealing with potentially complex options-related issues, such as understanding margin requirements for spreads, clarifying exercise/assignment procedures, or troubleshooting platform tools. Brokers offer various support channels, including phone, email, and online chat.⁹ Interactive Brokers provides multiple channels ⁹, while bank brokers like CommSec, Nabtrade, Westpac, and ANZ likely leverage their existing extensive customer service infrastructure.⁷

The critical factor is not just availability but expertise. Support staff primarily trained on simple share transactions or other products may struggle to adequately address sophisticated options queries. Brokers with a strong focus on active traders or a significant institutional background, like Interactive Brokers ³, may potentially offer support staff with more specialized options knowledge compared to mass-market platforms where options might be a smaller part of the business. Waiting times and the quality of responses can vary significantly between brokers, impacting the trading experience, especially when urgent assistance is needed.

9. Regulatory Compliance and Security

Trading involves trust, making regulatory compliance and broker security paramount considerations.

ASIC Regulation: As established, using a broker holding an Australian Financial Services License (AFSL) and regulated by ASIC is non-negotiable for Australian investors.⁵ This ensures adherence to Australian laws regarding financial services, disclosure, and client protection. All brokers profiled in Table 1 meet this requirement, with their AFSL numbers providing proof of registration.³

Client Fund Protection: ASIC regulations require brokers to keep client money separate from the firm’s own operational funds. Many brokers explicitly state they hold client funds in segregated trust accounts with authorized deposit-taking institutions. Interactive Brokers highlights its use of individual segregated accounts within the ASX Clear Derivatives Clearing System (DCS) for client ETO positions, ensuring they are kept separate from other clients and any potential house positions.³

Broker Stability and Financial Backing: The financial health and stability of the brokerage firm itself provide an additional layer of security. Interactive Brokers Group emphasizes its strong capital position, conservative balance sheet, and automated risk controls designed to protect both the firm and its clients.³ Brokers affiliated with major Australian banks, such as CommSec (Commonwealth Bank), Nabtrade (National Australia Bank), Westpac Broking, and ANZ Share Investing, benefit from the perceived stability and substantial backing of their parent institutions.⁴

CHESS Sponsorship: While options contracts themselves are not CHESS-sponsored, the underlying shares received upon exercise (for calls) or delivered upon assignment (for puts) can be. CHESS (Clearing House Electronic Subregister System) sponsorship means the shares are registered directly under the investor’s Holder Identification Number (HIN) on the ASX’s subregister. This provides transparency and makes transferring shares between brokers easier. Many Australian brokers, including CommSec, Nabtrade, CMC Markets (for CHESS-sponsored accounts), Webull, Pearler, and Superhero, offer CHESS sponsorship for shares.⁹ Some international brokers, or brokers using different models, might hold shares in a custodian arrangement instead. For options traders who frequently end up holding or delivering the underlying stock, understanding the broker’s share holding structure (CHESS vs. Custodian) is relevant.

Choosing an ASIC-regulated broker with clear client fund segregation practices and demonstrable financial stability minimizes counterparty risk, which remains a background consideration even when trading exchange-listed products.

10. User Reviews and Independent Comparisons

While broker marketing materials and official documentation provide essential information, user reviews and independent comparisons offer valuable real-world perspectives on performance, usability, and service quality.

Synthesized Feedback:

Interactive Brokers (IBKR): Frequently recommended in forums like Reddit, especially for US options trading, due to its very low costs and powerful platform (TWS).¹⁶ However, the complexity of TWS is a recurring theme, often described as having a steep learning curve and a user interface that is “ok” but not necessarily intuitive.⁹ Its suitability for advanced or cost-conscious traders is often highlighted.⁹ Independent reviews consistently rank IBKR highly, particularly for professional and international trading.⁹
CommSec: As Australia’s largest online broker ⁴, it benefits from brand recognition and integration with CBA banking. Its platform is generally considered user-friendly.⁴ However, its costs, particularly for options (with high minimums per leg cited ¹²), are often perceived as less competitive compared to specialists like IBKR.¹²
CMC Markets: Mentioned by users as a platform used for ASX options, described as functional (“does the job”) but potentially requiring supplementary external tools for analysis like valuation or implied volatility calculations.¹⁶ Comparison sites note its wide range of instruments including options and CFDs.¹⁰ Options pricing appears competitive with other non-specialist online brokers but higher than IBKR.¹²
Nabtrade: Similar to CommSec, offers the convenience of integration with NAB banking.⁷ Its platform may have premium tiers for active traders.¹⁰ Costs for options appear comparable to CommSec and CMC based on comparison data.¹²
Webull: Actively marketed as low-cost ¹⁹, but user feedback and detailed analysis often focus on its US share/option offering or free ETF trades.¹⁹ Specific feedback on its ASX ETO trading experience is less prevalent in the reviewed sources.
eToro & Tiger Brokers: Often feature in “best broker” lists ⁹, but primarily for share trading, copy trading (eToro), or US options (Tiger).⁹ They are generally not suitable choices for ASX ETO trading based on available product information.⁹ eToro’s fee structure can also be complex.¹⁰

Interpreting Reviews: It is crucial to interpret reviews critically. Comparison sites may have commercial relationships with brokers, potentially influencing rankings. User reviews on forums are subjective and can reflect isolated incidents or specific trading styles. A recurring theme across multiple reviews (e.g., IBKR’s complexity, CommSec’s ease of use but higher cost) carries more weight.

A significant challenge is filtering reviews to find feedback specifically relevant to ASX options trading. Many reviews focus on general share trading, platform usability for stocks, or experiences with international markets or CFDs. Platform stability during high volatility, the ease of executing multi-leg options strategies, the accuracy of options data feeds, and the quality of support for options-specific queries are key areas where user feedback is particularly valuable but may be harder to find amidst broader commentary.¹⁶ Practical issues like platform glitches, order execution problems for complex spreads, or unexpected fee applications are often surfaced in user reviews rather than official materials.

11. Broker Profiles: Leading Contenders for ASX Options

Based on the analysis of ASX ETO availability, costs, platforms, regulation, and reputation, the following brokers emerge as leading contenders for self-directed retail investors trading ASX options in Australia.

1. Interactive Brokers (IBKR) Australia (AFSL: 453554)

Overview: A global brokerage powerhouse known for broad market access, extremely competitive pricing, and a sophisticated trading platform.³ Offers direct access to ASX ETOs (equity and index).³
Costs: Features very low commissions on ASX options (e.g., $0.33-$2.00 per contract depending on source/premium, with low minimums ~$1.10-$6.00).¹¹ No inactivity fees.⁹ Potential fees for real-time data may apply depending on usage/status. Low FX conversion fees for international trading.¹³
Platform: Offers the advanced Trader Workstation (TWS) desktop platform, a simpler IBKR Desktop, a web-based Client Portal, and mobile apps.¹⁵ TWS provides extensive options analytics (Greeks, IV analysis, scanners), strategy builders, and algorithmic order types. Highly capable but has a significant learning curve.⁹
Support/Education: Provides a web-based help centre, email, phone, and chat support.⁹ Offers educational materials and paper trading.³ Support expertise likely higher for complex products due to active trader focus.
Regulation/Reputation: ASIC regulated.³ Strong emphasis on capital strength, client asset protection via ASX Clear DCS segregation for ETOs.³ Highly regarded by active and professional traders globally ¹⁵, frequently recommended for low costs.¹¹
Pros: Lowest ASX options commissions, powerful and feature-rich platform for advanced analysis and strategies, broad market access in one account, strong regulatory standing and security focus.
Cons: Platform (TWS) complexity can be daunting for beginners, interface may feel dated to some users.

2. Commonwealth Securities (CommSec) (AFSL: 238814)

Overview: Australia’s largest online broker, owned by Commonwealth Bank.⁴ Offers ASX ETOs alongside shares and other products.⁴
Costs: Options commissions are higher, cited at 0.24% with a significant minimum of $24.95 per leg.¹² Standard share trading fees are tiered based on size and settlement account.¹⁴ Potential fees for premium data.¹²
Platform: Proprietary web platform and mobile app, generally considered user-friendly and integrated with CBA banking.⁴ Options trading functionality is available but may lack the advanced analytical tools and strategy builders of specialist platforms.¹²
Support/Education: Offers educational resources via ‘CommSec Learn’.⁴ Benefits from CBA’s extensive customer support network, though specialized options expertise level is unverified.
Regulation/Reputation: ASIC regulated.⁴ Backed by Australia’s largest bank. Offers CHESS sponsorship for shares.¹⁰ Widely used and trusted, particularly by existing CBA customers.
Pros: Platform simplicity and ease of use, seamless integration with CBA accounts, strong brand recognition and backing, CHESS sponsorship.
Cons: Significantly higher options commissions and minimums compared to IBKR, platform may lack depth for advanced options strategies and analysis.

3. CMC Markets Stockbroking (AFSL: 238054)

Overview: A global provider offering CFDs, Forex, and direct share and options trading.¹⁰ Offers ASX ETOs.⁸
Costs: Options commissions cited at 0.30% with a $30 minimum per leg ¹², placing it between IBKR and the major bank brokers. Offers CHESS sponsorship option for shares.¹⁰ Data fees likely apply for real-time streaming data, potentially via IRESS.¹²
Platform: Offers its proprietary “Next Generation” platform and potentially access to IRESS ViewPoint.¹² Platform includes charting and analysis tools.¹⁰ User feedback suggests it’s functional for ASX options but might benefit from external analysis tools.¹⁶
Support/Education: Provides a knowledge hub with educational resources and demo accounts.¹⁰ Standard support channels available.
Regulation/Reputation: ASIC regulated.⁸ Established global presence. Offers CHESS sponsorship.¹⁰ Generally well-regarded, particularly for its CFD offering.
Pros: Offers ASX ETOs and CHESS sponsorship, platform may offer a balance between usability and features (especially if IRESS is used), costs potentially lower than major bank brokers.
Cons: Options commissions higher than IBKR, reliance on external tools for advanced analysis might be necessary depending on platform version used, potential data fees.

4. Nabtrade (AFSL: 243430)

Overview: The online investing arm of National Australia Bank (NAB).⁷ Provides access to ASX ETOs alongside shares and other investments.⁸
Costs: Options commissions cited at 0.35% with a $34.95 minimum per leg ¹², similar to CommSec and relatively high. Standard share trading fees apply.⁷ Potential for inactivity fees after 1 year.⁷
Platform: Proprietary web platform and mobile app, likely focusing on ease of use and integration with NAB banking. Offers premium tiers with enhanced features like charting.¹⁰ Options analysis tools likely less comprehensive than specialist platforms.
Support/Education: Leverages NAB’s support infrastructure. Offers educational resources.
Regulation/Reputation: ASIC regulated.⁷ Backed by a major Australian bank. Offers CHESS sponsorship for shares.¹⁰ Trusted brand, particularly for NAB customers.
Pros: Platform simplicity and integration with NAB banking, strong brand trust and backing, CHESS sponsorship.
Cons: High options commissions and minimums, platform likely lacks depth for advanced options traders, potential inactivity fee.

(Other potential contenders like Bell Direct (using IRESS) ⁸ or Webull ⁸ could be considered, but Bell Direct’s costs are similar to Nabtrade’s ¹², and Webull’s ASX ETO specific offering, costs, and platform features require closer scrutiny beyond the available snippets focused on US markets).

12. Conclusion and Recommendations

Selecting the optimal broker for trading ASX Exchange Traded Options (ETOs) in Australia requires a careful alignment of the broker’s offerings with the individual trader’s priorities, experience level, and trading style. There is no single “best” broker for everyone; the ideal choice involves trade-offs between cost, platform sophistication, ease of use, and support.

The analysis reveals distinct tiers among the leading contenders:

For the Cost-Sensitive and Advanced Options Trader: Interactive Brokers (IBKR) stands out as the clear leader. Its significantly lower commission structure for ASX options, coupled with low minimum charges per trade, makes it highly attractive for active traders and those executing multi-leg strategies where costs can accumulate rapidly.¹¹ Its Trader Workstation (TWS) platform, while complex, offers an unparalleled suite of analytical tools, strategy builders, and order types essential for sophisticated options trading.³ The trade-off is the considerable learning curve associated with TWS.⁹ Traders prioritizing cost efficiency and powerful tools, and willing to invest time in learning the platform, will find IBKR hard to beat.
For Traders Prioritizing Simplicity and Integrated Banking: CommSec and Nabtrade offer viable alternatives, particularly for existing customers of Commonwealth Bank or National Australia Bank, respectively. Their platforms are generally more intuitive and user-friendly, and they offer the convenience of seamless integration with banking services.⁴ They also provide the security of CHESS sponsorship for resulting share positions.¹⁰ However, this convenience comes at a price, with significantly higher options commissions and substantial minimum charges per leg compared to IBKR.¹² These brokers are better suited for less frequent options traders or those who value ease of use and brand trust above minimizing trading costs.
For a Balanced Approach or Alternative Platforms: CMC Markets and potentially Bell Direct (often utilising the IRESS platform) occupy a middle ground. Their options commissions, while higher than IBKR, may be slightly more competitive than the major bank brokers.¹² CMC offers its own platform alongside potential IRESS access, while Bell Direct typically relies on IRESS.¹² IRESS is a powerful platform favoured by many active traders but usually involves data subscription fees. These brokers could appeal to traders seeking more advanced features than the basic bank platforms offer, without necessarily needing the full complexity or accepting the interface of IBKR’s TWS, provided the associated costs (commissions and data fees) align with their budget. User feedback suggests CMC’s platform is functional but may require external tools for deeper analysis.¹⁶

Final Recommendations:

Define Priorities: Before choosing, investors must clearly define their priorities: Is minimizing cost paramount? Is an advanced platform with deep analytics essential? Or is simplicity and integration with existing banking relationships more important?
Verify Current Information: Brokerage fees, platform features, and product offerings can change. It is crucial to consult the broker’s official website, Product Disclosure Statement (PDS), and Financial Services Guide (FSG) for the most up-to-date information before opening an account.
Consider a Demo Account: Where available (e.g., IBKR, CMC Markets), utilize a paper trading or demo account to test the platform’s interface, tools, and workflow for options trading before committing real capital.¹⁰ This is particularly important for complex platforms like TWS.
Start Small: Regardless of the broker chosen, new options traders should start with simple strategies and small position sizes while familiarizing themselves with the platform and the dynamics of options pricing and risk.

By carefully weighing the detailed comparisons provided in this report against their individual requirements, Australian investors can select a brokerage firm that effectively facilitates their ASX options trading activities.

Download PDF

Works cited

Cost of trading options – ASX fees, accessed April 19, 2025, https://www.asx.com.au/markets/market-resources/asx-schedule-of-fees/cost-of-trading-options
Options Trading in Australia 2025 – Finder, accessed April 19, 2025, https://www.finder.com.au/share-trading/options-trading
Trading ASX Options: Why you should choose Interactive Brokers – IBKR Guides, accessed April 19, 2025, https://www.ibkrguides.com/kb/trading-asx-options.htm
Exchange Traded Options – CommSec, accessed April 19, 2025, https://www.commsec.com.au/products/eto-options.html
ASIC (Australia) Regulated Forex Brokers – TradingPedia, accessed April 19, 2025, https://www.tradingpedia.com/forex-brokers/asic-regulated-forex-brokers/
ASIC (Australia) Regulated Forex Brokers – BestBrokers.com, accessed April 19, 2025, https://www.bestbrokers.com/forex-brokers/asic-regulated-forex-brokers/
Top 8 Australian Stock Brokers (April 2025) – Securities.io, accessed April 19, 2025, https://www.securities.io/australian-stock-brokers/
Full service and online brokers – ASX, accessed April 19, 2025, https://www.asx.com.au/investors/start-investing/find-a-broker-adviser/full-service-and-online-brokers
9 Best Online Brokers In Australia (2025) – Arielle Executive, accessed April 19, 2025, https://arielle.com.au/best-online-broker-australia/
Our Pick Of The Best Share Trading Platforms For Australians – Forbes, accessed April 19, 2025, https://www.forbes.com/advisor/au/investing/best-share-trading-platforms-australia/
The best options trading platforms in Australia 2025 | finder.com.au, accessed April 19, 2025, https://www.finder.com.au/share-trading/best-options-trading-platforms
Compare – Volatility | Elite Options Trading Platform – Advanced Strategies and Tools, accessed April 19, 2025, https://volatility.com.au/compare
GlobalTrader Pricing | Interactive Brokers Australia Pty. Ltd., accessed April 19, 2025, https://www.interactivebrokers.com.au/en/trading/globaltrader/pricing.php
Rates & Fees – CommSec, accessed April 19, 2025, https://www.commsec.com.au/support/rates-and-fees.html
Home | Interactive Brokers LLC, accessed April 19, 2025, https://www.interactivebrokers.com/
Best Options trading platform for Australians (individuals) : r/AusFinance – Reddit, accessed April 19, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/AusFinance/comments/1d95us8/best_options_trading_platform_for_australians/
Home | tastytrade australia | The market waits for no one. See how tastytrade works for you., accessed April 19, 2025, https://www.tastyworks.com.au/
ASIC Regulated Forex Brokers – ForexChurch.com, accessed April 19, 2025, https://www.forexchurch.com/asic-regulated-forex-brokers
Webull Australia: Trading Platform for ASX, US Stocks, ETF and more, accessed April 19, 2025, https://www.webull.com.au/
Day Trade US Options with Commissions Starting from US$0.50 – Webull Australia, accessed April 19, 2025, https://www.webull.com.au/us-options
Trade Options in Australia with the No. 1 Platform | IG AU, accessed April 19, 2025, https://www.ig.com/au/options-trading
Find a broker or adviser – ASX, accessed April 19, 2025, https://www.asx.com.au/investors/start-investing/find-a-broker-adviser
Online trading platforms comparison – Passive Investing Australia, accessed April 19, 2025, https://passiveinvestingaustralia.com/online-trading-platforms-comparison/
6 Best ASIC-Regulated Forex Brokers for 2025 – FXEmpire, accessed April 19, 2025, https://www.fxempire.com/brokers/best/asic